A quiet Friday night in Contra Costa County turned into a tragedy when an SUV left westbound State Route 24 near Orinda, killing two young women and seriously injuring two other young people. Families are now facing grief, hospital bills, and many unanswered questions.
Highway 24 is a busy commuter corridor that connects the East Bay to Oakland, and the Caldecott Tunnel, and crashes along this stretch can change lives in seconds. In the hours after a highway crash like this one, families often face a flood of urgent concerns at once: reaching loved ones at the hospital, making arrangements after an unimaginable loss.
And learning what happened from investigators who are still piecing together the evidence. Younger passengers and drivers are especially vulnerable on high-speed roadways, and the aftermath can reach far beyond the people in the vehicle, touching parents, siblings, classmates, and friends.
For those who survived, the physical recovery may take months or years, and the financial strain of emergency care, surgery, and rehabilitation can arrive long before any answers about fault do. Understanding the options available during this period can help families make careful decisions while they focus on healing.

What Happened on Westbound Highway 24
According to the California Highway Patrol (CHP), officers responded just after 10 p.m. on Friday to a report of a single-vehicle crash on westbound Highway 24, just east of Camino Pablo in Orinda.
A preliminary investigation indicates that a gray Infiniti SUV was traveling westbound when it left the roadway and crashed. The CHP has said the reason the vehicle left the road is still under investigation.
Responding officers found four occupants injured, ranging in age from 16 to 20. Two of them, both passengers, were declared dead at the scene. They were an 18-year-old and a 20-year-old, both from San Francisco. The 19-year-old driver was taken to a hospital and treated for moderate injuries. A 16-year-old passenger was taken to a hospital with critical injuries.
What Investigators Have Shared So Far
The CHP reported that the driver and one of the passengers who died were not wearing seat belts, and that the driver was ejected from the vehicle. Authorities also said drugs or alcohol do not appear to be factors in the crash.
Investigations like this one often take weeks or months to reach conclusions. Speed, driver fatigue, distraction, mechanical failure, a tire problem, or roadway conditions can all play a role in a vehicle leaving the highway, and no single explanation should be assumed until investigators finish their work.
Because the CHP has described its findings as preliminary, the picture of what happened may change as the investigation moves forward. Officers typically document the scene, measure the path the vehicle took off the roadway, inspect the SUV, and interview survivors and any witnesses. The results are later compiled into an official collision report.
The statement that drugs or alcohol do not appear to be factors helps narrow the list of possible explanations, but it does not answer the central question of why the SUV left the highway. The Contra Costa County Sheriff’s Office, which handles the coroner’s duties, identified the two women who died, and its work may also contribute to the final findings.
For the families, these official conclusions can carry real weight because they often shape how insurance carriers evaluate a claim and what additional evidence may need to be preserved. Anyone who saw the SUV before the crash or who may have been driving nearby on westbound Highway 24 that night is encouraged to share what they remember with the CHP.
Seat Belt Use and Its Effect on a California Injury Claim
California Vehicle Code §27315 requires drivers and passengers to wear seat belts. When someone was unbuckled, insurance companies sometimes argue that the person bears part of the blame for the severity of their injuries.
California follows a pure comparative fault system, established in Li v. Yellow Cab Co., which means an injured person can still recover damages even if they are assigned a portion of fault. Their recovery is simply reduced by their percentage of responsibility.
For families, this is an important point. Seat belt use is one factor among many, and it does not automatically erase a claim. How the crash happened, who was responsible for it, and what evidence exists all matter. Seat belt use is one of the first issues an insurance company is likely to raise after a serious crash, and the CHP’s report that two of the occupants were not buckled means it may come up here.
In California, an insurer can argue that an unbuckled occupant contributed to the severity of their own injuries, which can reduce the compensation owed under the state’s pure comparative fault rules. However, the argument has real limits.
Under Vehicle Code §27315, failing to wear a seat belt does not by itself establish negligence as a matter of law, and the defense generally has to show that the lack of a belt actually made the injuries worse than they otherwise would have been. That is a question that often calls for medical and accident reconstruction evidence, not assumptions.
It also does not change who caused the crash in the first place, since a driver’s negligence or a defective vehicle part remains a separate issue from what happened inside the SUV. Each person in the vehicle is evaluated individually, so the position of a buckled passenger can look very different from that of someone who was not.
For grieving families, hearing that a loved one may be blamed in part can be painful, but it should not discourage them from seeking guidance, because many valid claims move forward even when seat belt use is disputed.
Who May Be Legally Responsible After a Single-Vehicle Crash
A crash with no other car involved does not mean no one can be held accountable. Under California Civil Code §1714, every person is generally responsible for injuries caused by a lack of ordinary care. If a driver’s negligence caused the crash, passengers and their families may be able to pursue a claim through the driver’s auto insurance coverage.
Other sources of liability may also exist depending on what the evidence shows. A defective tire, steering component, or other vehicle part may point to a product liability claim against a manufacturer. If a dangerous roadway condition contributed, such as poor drainage, missing or damaged guardrails, or inadequate signage, a public entity may be held responsible under Government Code §835.
Claims against public entities follow much shorter deadlines, and a written claim must generally be presented within six months of the incident, so early legal guidance is especially important.
A crash with no other vehicle involved can leave families wondering whether anyone can be held accountable, but California law often allows for more than one basis for liability. The most common starting point is the driver, since Civil Code §1714 holds people responsible for injuries caused by a failure to use ordinary care, and passengers hurt by a negligent driver may be able to seek compensation through that driver’s auto insurance.
If the driver was operating a vehicle owned by someone else, the owner may also face liability under California’s permissive use statute, Vehicle Code §17150, though those claims are subject to statutory limits, and an owner who knowingly lent a car to an unfit or unsafe driver could face a separate negligent entrustment claim.
Responsibility can also extend beyond the people involved. A tire failure, steering problem, or other defect may point to a product liability claim against a manufacturer, and improper repairs or maintenance may implicate the shop that serviced the SUV.
Because Highway 24 is a state route, the condition of the roadway can also matter, and dangerous conditions such as damaged guardrails, poor drainage, or inadequate signage may support a claim against a public entity under Government Code §835.
Which of these theories applies, if any, depends entirely on what the investigation and the physical evidence ultimately show, which is why preserving the vehicle, its data, and the crash scene details early can make a meaningful difference.
Wrongful Death and Survival Claims in California
When a person dies because of someone else’s negligence, California law allows certain family members to bring a wrongful death action under Code of Civil Procedure §377.60. Eligible parties generally include a surviving spouse or domestic partner, children, and others who would inherit under California’s intestate succession rules, as well as certain financially dependent family members. Wrongful death damages can include the loss of financial support, loss of companionship, and funeral and burial expenses.
Separately, Code of Civil Procedure §377.30 allows a survival action, which lets the deceased person’s estate pursue the claims the person could have brought had they lived. These may include medical expenses and pain and suffering endured before death. The general statute of limitations for personal injury and wrongful death in California is two years under Code of Civil Procedure §335.1, though exceptions can shorten or extend that window.
Protecting a Critically Injured Young Passenger
When a minor suffers a catastrophic injury, the legal and medical road ahead can be long. Future surgeries, rehabilitation, therapy, specialized equipment, and lost future earning capacity may all need to be considered.
California law can extend filing deadlines for injured minors, but those protections have limits, particularly where a public entity is involved. Because evidence like vehicle data, scene photographs, and witness accounts can disappear quickly, acting early helps protect the family’s options.
When a teenager survives a crash with critical injuries, the legal questions can feel secondary, yet the decisions made in the first weeks can shape the family’s options for years. A critical injury at age 16 may involve emergency surgery, extended hospitalization, rehabilitation, and ongoing therapy, and the full extent of long-term effects, including lost future earning capacity, is often not clear until well after the patient is stable.
California law offers some added protection for minors, since the filing deadline for a personal injury claim is generally paused until a young person turns 18 under Code of Civil Procedure §352, but that protection has limits.
Claims against a public entity follow a much shorter timeline and may require a written claim within 6 months, though California law allows a late-claim application for minors in certain circumstances. Any settlement on behalf of a minor must also be approved by a court, which is meant to ensure the money is protected and used for the young person’s benefit, and the court may direct funds into a blocked account or a structured arrangement.
Parents may have their own claim as well, including recovery of medical expenses they have paid or are responsible for. Evidence like the vehicle’s data, scene photographs, and witness accounts can be lost quickly, so speaking with an attorney early can help a family protect every option while they focus on their child’s recovery.
How Settlements Are Valued in Serious Injury and Death Cases
No two cases are alike, but attorneys commonly use two approaches to estimate a claim’s value. The multiplier method adds up economic damages, such as medical bills and lost income, and then multiplies the total by a factor that reflects the severity of the harm, typically a higher factor for catastrophic or permanent injuries. The per diem method assigns a daily dollar value to pain and suffering and multiplies it by the number of days a person is expected to endure it.
Catastrophic injury settlement calculators can offer a rough starting point, but they cannot capture long-term care costs, the impact on a young person’s future, or the disputed fault arguments an insurer may raise. Every real case depends on the evidence, the available insurance coverage, and the specific losses a family has suffered.
Fatal Accident Settlement Calculators and Why They Matter When Estimating Case Value
A fatal accident settlement calculator is an online tool that gives families a rough estimate of what a wrongful death claim might be worth, based on the details they enter. Most calculators begin with economic damages, such as funeral and burial costs, medical bills incurred before death, and the income and benefits the loved one would have contributed to the family over a lifetime.
They then estimate non-economic damages, such as the loss of companionship, guidance, and emotional support, by applying either the multiplier method, which multiplies total economic losses by a factor reflecting the severity of the loss, or the per diem method, which assigns a daily dollar amount over a period of time.
The real value of these tools is that they help grieving families understand which categories of damages California law recognizes under Code of Civil Procedure §377.60 and provide a starting point for conversations with an attorney. Still, a calculator is only an educational estimate and cannot predict what a case will actually be worth.
It cannot account for available insurance coverage, which often limits what can be collected, or for disputed fault, which can reduce a recovery under California’s pure comparative fault rules. It also cannot capture the age and earning potential of the deceased, the number of surviving family members, or the strength of the evidence.
A free consultation with an experienced wrongful death attorney is the most reliable way to move from a general estimate to a realistic evaluation of a family’s claim. Call us now at 1-855-508-9565 to speak with the experts.
Speak With a California Wrongful Death and Serious Injury Attorney
“No family should have to face a night like this one while also worrying about medical bills, insurance adjusters, and legal deadlines. If you or someone you love was hurt in this crash, please know that you do not have to figure out what comes next alone. Evidence can disappear quickly, and strict filing deadlines apply, so speaking with an attorney early can protect your family’s rights while you focus on healing. At GJEL, we handle these cases on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Our team is here to listen, answer your questions, and fight for the answers and support your family deserves.” – Andy Gillin, Managing Partner, GJEL Accident Attorneys
If you or someone you love was affected by a crash on Highway 24 or anywhere in California, GJEL Accident Attorneys is here to listen. With more than 40 years of experience and over $950 million recovered for clients, our team understands how overwhelming these moments can be. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. Call us anytime at 1-855-508-9565 or visit our Sacramento office for a free consultation.
Local Resources for Those Affected
California Highway Patrol (CHP), Contra Costa Area Office. The CHP is the agency investigating this crash. The office is located at 5001 Blum Road, Martinez, CA 94553. Anyone with information about the crash can call 925-387-1900, the number given in this crash’s report, or the office’s main line at (925) 646-4980. Witnesses can also email 320Investigations@chp.ca.gov. Office details and hours are available at https://www.chp.ca.gov/Find-an-Office/Golden-Gate-Division/Offices/(320)-Contra-Costa
CHP Crash Report Requests. Once the investigation is complete, a proper party of interest, such as a driver, passenger, parent of a minor, legal guardian, vehicle owner, or legal representative, can request a copy of the crash report. Requests can be made online through the CHP Crash Portal at https://crashes.chp.ca.gov, or in person or by mail to the nearest CHP Area office using form CHP 190. Instructions are available at https://www.chp.ca.gov/traffic/request-a-crash-report, and the form can be downloaded at https://www.chp.ca.gov/siteassets/files/chp190.pdf
Orinda Police Services (Contra Costa County Office of the Sheriff). Orinda does not operate an independent police department. The City contracts with the Contra Costa County Office of the Sheriff for police services. Information about Orinda’s police services is available at https://www.cocosheriff.org/bureaus/field-operations/special-operations-division/orinda. For non-emergency matters, the Sheriff’s dispatch line is (925) 646-2441. In an emergency, always call 911.
Contra Costa County Sheriff-Coroner, Coroner’s Division. The Coroner’s Division handles death investigations in the county, and families may need to work with this office regarding the release of a loved one. The division is located at 1960 Muir Road, 1st Floor, Martinez, CA 94553, and can be reached at 925-313-2850. Information and forms, including the Coroner’s Release Form, are available at https://cocosheriff.org/bureaus/support-services/coroner-s-division
Caltrans District 4 (Oakland). Caltrans maintains Highway 24 and serves Contra Costa County through its District 4 office at 111 Grand Avenue, Oakland, CA 94612. The general information line is (510) 286-4444. Concerns about roadway conditions, signage, or guardrails along State Route 24 can be directed to the District 4 Public Affairs office at https://dot.ca.gov/caltrans-near-me/district-4/d4-programs/d4-public-affairs
Contra Costa County Superior Court. If a civil lawsuit is eventually filed, it would be handled through the Contra Costa County Superior Court. The Wakefield Taylor Courthouse is located at 725 Court Street, Martinez, CA 94553, and the main court line is (925) 608-1000. Court locations, hours, and filing information are available at https://contracosta.courts.ca.gov



